Hi worldalpha, thank you for PM'ing me your opinions of me, but I'm quite happy to discuss these things in the public forum. Anyway I fully stand by my comments made in this thread. I truly believe that a MMORTS/eRepublik/Evony mashup would be a truly horrendous game, but I wish you luck all the same.
I'm trying to take you seriously as an expert, but when your game has a No Rank in Alexa, it is really hard to believe it. Maybe wait til my game is out, and play it, before calling anything horrendous. I'm tempted to comment more on your "games" but I'll refrain for now.
Seriously, I don't get it. I have similar posts at other sites, and gotten honest and constructive feedback. This site is for indie developers and as one just trying to get some feedback, all I get is grief. I would understand if it was a site full of AAA games, and the general public (not indie developers & gamers) was commenting. I've gotten way better feedback from reddit and onrpg than here. Anyways, this type of stuff motivates me. My site is going to be far from horrendous. It may not be your cup of tea, but lots of people will enjoy it.