Even though you may not like YYG, they have done some nice things for Game Maker (version 7, make ports, C++ rewrite that is in the works, etc.).
I never really bothered with the YYG site, I stopped visiting the forums a while before version 7 came out (I didn't like the atmosphere there). From my experience I don't think that the 5-star rating system means all that much there (my impression is that there is a lot of up/down rating without any reasons given. I don't really like the idea of rating system in numbers (seeing as anything below 7/10 is usually seen as "bad" or harshly reviewed, and then there are arguments over numbers, etc.) I'd rather read a bunch of reviews where people explain what they liked/disliked, seeing as there have been many cases where something the reviewer doesn't like sounds like something I would enjoy.
I never did understand why they would use a 6-star rating system though. It's doesn't achieve anything.
Speed was always a much bigger issue for me
This would be nice, even though I barely look at the site.