next »

[Kingel]

I think a pastel blue or orange would fit better with the theme than salmon.

I like those colors, too. How about some kind of gradient for the numbers as well?

[caffeine]

^This works for me.

[Kren]

it's really hard to read the 0% and the 10% words...

[Core Xii]

The black in the progress bars is easily identified as the background [...] the bars stand out more because they are a changing entity, while the background is static.

Sure it's easily identified, but that's the problem; You have to actually look at it and identify it. If it's unidentified stuff in your peripheral vision - as it is when you're reading thread titles - it draws way too much attention. Dare I say the game's name is more important than its completeness.

The backgrounds are not static. Some threads use these icons, others don't. Therefore the background changes from row to row - And that only reinforces my point. The background of other icons/no icon is white; Therefore the background here should be white as well, so that it does not change like you said.

[phubans]

This is how they should look:



Now you can't say that the only thing I've done for this community is bring humor 

[ink.inc]

o wow

[Inanimate]

This is how they should look:



Now you can't say that the only thing I've done for this community is bring humor 

yessss wonderful blue

I don't like the "Done" button, but everything else is AMAZING

[Kingel]

This is how they should look:



Now you can't say that the only thing I've done for this community is bring humor 

Ooh! Nice.



I added some shiny stuff. Too much?

[mokesmoe]

I like it, especially the 3d-looking bars.

[phubans]

This is how they should look:



Now you can't say that the only thing I've done for this community is bring humor 

Ooh! Nice.



I added some shiny stuff. Too much?

I think it's working really well on the bars but the done icon isn't reading too well. Maybe make a few of the twinkles larger, because right now they look more like artifacts.

[ANtY]

No, they look good. Add them now :D

[Derek]

I added some shiny stuff. Too much?

This.

Also, good work, phubans.

I'm going to wait a bit longer because I have a feeling that in a week these suckers will be animated.

[Oddball]

I have a feeling that in a week these suckers will be animated.

Ha! At this rate we're going to need progress icon just to show us the progress of the DevLog progress icon.

[phubans]

Actually, I think they should remain static because otherwise it would be too crazy?

I think only the done button should be animated, and it should increment from the first state to the last, and then flash when it hits the done state, you know? I could do this, but I don't feel like messing with it right now :/ :\ :0

[Loren Schmidt]

These are neat. I also totally appreciate that they will encourage people to make actual content instead of staying in the preproduction phase for too long (tempting though that is).

Hurrah for completing things!

[Lee]

I edited it to make the fist progress block and the first percentages more visible and made some of the sparkles a bit more visible too. I also changed the look of the blocks slightly.
Arachne:phubans:Edit:

[ness io kain]

I think the sparkly "done" looks kind of tacky, but that might just be me.
Otherwise, everything else has been cool.

[Lee]

Yeah the done thing being in a box is kind of weird, don't see why the box has to be so big either.

Better?

[phubans]

I dunno, the bars lost that subtle little highlight on them that was working really nice after you edited them. I'm not sure if this last iteration is an improvement...

[increpare]

I find the grey text in the current ones difficult to read.  I personally would rather the text be kept readable (at all percentages).