What about the Soldat guy? I think he'd be a worthy contender.
Isn't "Soldat Guy" a custom guy with a gun, though? Not exactly... iconic. Or even recognisable. The character, not the game. Game's pretty great.
Also I think it does it's job with introducing indie characters quite well [...]
Yeah it has! Before I started helping out here I had never heard of Lugaru, Dwarf Fortress, Lyle in Cube Sector or Cave Story (
) before, to name a few off the top of my head.
Now I'm a rabid Overgrowth follower!
This. I mean, I knew of all of them before this project started, but not everyone does. Don't lose sight of the fact TIGSource is one of the more rabid indie gamer sites. Many folks with a purely casual interest would only know one or two. For a strong start, we need characters many people identify with, from games that should be known. We could likely stretch the roster out to... fourty-odd characters from fourty-odd developers before obscurity genuinely becomes a problem.
PLUS: We're totally open to new characters, Adamski. Iji got fast-tracked within the month her game was released, I recall. People played it, people enjoyed it, it was decided she needed a place. Now she's part of milestone one. Same goes for Xoda Rap.
EDIT: Forgot to say, I totally think Soldat should be given some loving in-game. It's well known and pretty damn good. Just not sure if the character's the way to go. But hey, them's just my opinions.