next »

[akashkhatkale]

Hey guys,
I am currently developing an isometric game like ketchapp's STACK.
I have designed ui for that game. I need your opinions on that UI.
Which one is nice ?
Thanks,
Akash

1) https://www.dropbox.com/s/njk06da4yojoj1y/4.png?dl=0
2) https://www.dropbox.com/s/usf0tuw3qwbjar8/5.png?dl=0

[Xorglord]

Hey!

Not a UI designer or anything, but I liked the red one more (#4 I think). Felt like the red fit in better with the snow than the orange.

[Schnodderbalken]

I also think the red one looks better. The sign saying "cube stack" fits into the environment as one expects to have signs in a snow (ski?-)area. Also, it has a lot better contrast to the background. I would increase the size of "TAP TO PLAY" as this is the call to action button and should motivate the user to do something!

[akashkhatkale]

Thanks guys

[ArjenAwesome]

I prefer the red one, the contrast to the other elements of the menu is much clearer. Also making it part of the background is a nice touch. The yellow one has the problem of being the same color as the menu buttons, thus suggesting that they're part of the same "entity" meaning you probably expect to be able to press the logo. What I do think could be improved is the tap to play message in the red menu, the red on the background isn't looking that clean to me, perhaps make it a sign hanging below the other sign. Hope that helps you out.

[akashkhatkale]

I will post another pic after modifying it
Thanks

[akashkhatkale]

Here it is : https://www.dropbox.com/s/soqe80j8ngljz29/6.png?dl=0
How is it ??

[Xorglord]

I like this one a little more - although the rounded bottom on the poles of the sign looks weird. I'd go back to the flat bottom, it looks more like it's sticking out of the snow.

[twoscoop]

The red one for sure, and the new red one looks great!

[ArjenAwesome]

Much better indeed, looks much more consistent. Great work!

[akashkhatkale]

Thanks a lot guys
Does it looks polished ?

[Devr0s]

I prefer the second one overall. The red one stands out more but the orange buttons look more like objects in the world. The second where they are all orange is easier to understand. Try to have all your UI elements incorporate similar colors and designs.