next »

[Sunpeece]

http://civilitygame.blog.com

Let me know what you think.

I added a short overview

[Sunpeece]

Bump, out of 65 views I can't get 1 reply?

[Yrgkala]

You have no comprehensive description of the game; there isn't much to comment on.

[Sunpeece]

Sorry, I assumed people will read the "What Inspires Civility" post to see the main gist like 30+ people did on another forum I'm subscribed to. Anyways, the most comprehensive idea we have of the game is only a little ahead of what we already have at any given time. It's sort of a formless project when it comes to aims and goals. Nonetheless, I'm working on a post to describe some fundamental ideas for the project.

[ANtY]

I assume people are intelligent and read[...]

I'd assume that a person that would like to get any feedback from other forum users would make anything he can to provide the info to the users.

Not to throw a random link to the blog on which first post is about some music, second about wip artwork.

http://civilitygame.blog.com

Let me know what you think.

About what? The domain? The music? Artwork? Blog layout?


If you want ppl to feedback on this provide sth that is easy to percept: mockup/screenshot/short overview and then the long description, etc.

If you're lazy don't expect others to not be.

edit: check other threads and learn

[Sunpeece]

I assume people are intelligent and read[...]

I'd assume that a person that would like to get any feedback from other forum users would make anything he can to provide the info to the users.

Not to throw a random link to the blog on which first post is about some music, second about wip artwork.

http://civilitygame.blog.com

Let me know what you think.

About what? The domain? The music? Artwork? Blog layout?


If you want ppl to feedback on this provide sth that is easy to percept: mockup/screenshot/short overview and then the long description, etc.

If you're lazy don't expect others to not be.

edit: check other threads and learn

I didn't mean it like that, sorry. Well anyways, like I said, I'm working on a description of the core game ideas and it will be posted soon, thanks to feedback from this forum and another forum I frequent. I'm not lazy, I just haven't added those parts yet. They were just suggested and I'm working on something similar.

[ANtY]

Next time try to hold back with creating a thread till u have those basic things ready to show, other way it just looks like this and ppl can understand your intentions in a wrong way 

[Sunpeece]

Next time try to hold back with creating a thread till u have those basic things ready to show, other way it just looks like this and ppl can understand your intentions in a wrong way 

I did have something basic to show. Out of the 30+ replies on the other forum, people seemed to understand the gist of the project.

[ANtY]

Next time try to hold back with creating a thread till u have those basic things ready to show, other way it just looks like this and ppl can understand your intentions in a wrong way  

I did have something basic to show. Out of the 30+ replies on the other forum, people seemed to understand the gist of the project.

I guess it was a much smaller forum and ppl know you there, probably a forum in your native language with your countrymen?

I get nice amounts of feedback on Polish forums even if I post scraps but here on TIGsource there are a lot of ppl and projects and I get no replies no matter how hard I'd try (example). I guess we have to deal with it. And if your project has retro 8bit graphics you'll have for sure higher chances to get noticed here :p
Good luck

[kamac]

Hard to give you feedback out of one screenshot.

This, to be accurate:



And it's taken from your blog.

It seems that you have nothing to show yet, so the thread looks unattractive.

[Sunpeece]

I added a short overview

Well then. Maybe I'll lock the topic until there is more.

Edit: erm, how do I lock the topic on these forums?

[Franklin's Ghost]

There should be a button on the bottom left where you can lock and unlock

[Sunpeece]

There should be a button on the bottom left where you can lock and unlock

Alrighty, but I changed my mind